Key Takeaways
- Dutch Data Protection Authority has levied a €825 million (~$966 million) penalty against Uber for using automated systems to deactivate driver accounts without adequate human intervention.
- This penalty ranks as the second-highest GDPR fine in history, trailing only the €1.2 billion sanction imposed on Meta during 2023.
- Uber intends to challenge the ruling, characterizing the fine as excessive and questioning the accuracy of certain allegations.
- The investigation originated from grievances filed by French drivers during the 2018-2022 period, processed through Dutch channels due to Uber’s European headquarters location in the Netherlands.
- Digital rights organization PersonalData.io is organizing a collective legal action on behalf of impacted drivers seeking damages.
Uber is confronting a penalty approaching $1 billion from Dutch data protection officials concerning its management of driver account deactivations, representing one of Europe’s most substantial GDPR sanctions to date.
The Netherlands’ Data Protection Authority revealed a €825 million sanction, approximately $966 million, targeting Uber for terminating driver access through algorithmic systems while failing to provide sufficient advance notification or human evaluation of these determinations.
The penalty encompasses violations occurring throughout Europe between 2018 and 2022. Dutch authorities handled the enforcement because Uber maintains its European operational center in Amsterdam.
The investigation was initiated following a complaint from Brahim Ben Ali, a French Uber driver whose account was terminated in 2019. Ben Ali subsequently compiled statements from 170 additional drivers before submitting the collective complaint to Dutch regulators.
Ben Ali received assistance from PersonalData.io, a Swiss nonprofit focused on digital rights, which facilitated drivers’ efforts to obtain information regarding the algorithmic deactivation procedures.
Monique Verdier, deputy chair of the Dutch regulatory body, stated that Uber had “committed serious infringements.” She emphasized: “From one moment to the next they no longer had any income. A computer should not make decisions on its own that have major consequences.”
European GDPR legislation explicitly forbids purely algorithmic decision-making when such determinations substantially affect an individual’s economic well-being. Regulations mandate substantive human oversight and mechanisms for appealing automated decisions.
Uber contested multiple aspects of the regulatory findings. The company asserted that most suspensions were temporary in nature and that no permanent terminations occurred without human evaluation. Uber also emphasized that merely 126 European drivers faced deactivation due to poor customer ratings throughout 2021.
Uber to Challenge Ruling
Uber announced its intention to appeal the regulatory decision. A company representative stated: “We strongly disagree with this decision and disproportionate fine.” Uber maintained that its operational procedures incorporate human oversight and that drivers possess avenues to contest platform suspensions.
Dutch regulators determined the penalty amount as a percentage of Uber’s projected 2025 annual revenue.
This marks another chapter in Uber’s ongoing regulatory challenges with Dutch authorities. The same enforcement body previously assessed a €290 million penalty concerning drivers’ personal data management, along with an additional €10 million sanction for related violations. All three penalties originated from complaints submitted by the identical driver collective.
Collective Litigation in Development
Paul-Olivier Dehaye, who founded PersonalData.io, verified that the organization is developing a class action lawsuit to pursue financial compensation for affected drivers. Dehaye is simultaneously establishing a new enterprise named StartClaims to facilitate the litigation and extend support to additional gig economy disputes.
The fine trails only the €1.2 billion sanction levied against Meta by Irish authorities in 2023 for transmitting European Facebook user information to American servers. Meta continues to contest that ruling through appeals.
Uber stock (UBER) was trading up 0.32% at the time of reporting.
The post Uber (UBER) Hit with $966 Million GDPR Penalty for Algorithmic Driver Deactivations appeared first on Blockonomi.
